R(I)1/71

Hi Anne,

Here is the decision - I think it is in the Briefcase as well.

regards

Chris

Hi Anne

I don’t think that you need to get yourself bogged down in case law on this point.  It is a fundamental principle of law that he who alleges something must prove the truth of the allegation.  Thus he who seeks supersession must make out the ground for supersession.  Any judge will agree with you if you just simply point it out.

Thanks for the link, Chris, but unfortunately it’s the same one where only the first couple of lines of the decision appears.  Can’t find the full decision anywhere else.

I know I don’t need to go into this in depth, Nevip, but I do like to read at least a synopsis before I use a decision in an appeal, to ensure that I am clear about what I am quoting.

hi

here’s a link to page with decision on in toolkit-

http://www.rightsnet.org.uk/toolkit/industrial-injuries-disablement-benefit/

only first two lines on first page, but rest is there if you scroll down -

cheers ros

Thank you, Ros

Regards
Anne