Discussion archive

Top Other benefit issues topic #3383

Subject: "mother and son investigators" First topic | Last topic
suelees
                              

Welfare and Debt Advisor, Stephensons Solicitors, Wigan
Member since
28th Jan 2004

mother and son investigators
Tue 29-Apr-08 11:20 AM

Probably a pointless post but I just want to put my niggles down about recent instructions.

Mother and son respective DWP and LA fraud officers in a joint investigation - never come across that before. I assume it's acceptable but it's a bit like "cheese CAKE" - just not reet!

Client's had overpayment decisions from both JCP and LA before they'd even been interviewed under caution - another new one on me.

  

Top      

Replies to this topic
RE: mother and son investigators, Derek, 29th Apr 2008, #1
RE: mother and son investigators, jj, 29th Apr 2008, #2
      RE: mother and son investigators, nevip, 30th Apr 2008, #3
           RE: mother and son investigators, andyp4, 30th Apr 2008, #4
                RE: mother and son investigators, nevip, 30th Apr 2008, #5
                     RE: mother and son investigators, claire hodgson, 30th Apr 2008, #6
                          RE: mother and son investigators, nevip, 30th Apr 2008, #7
                               RE: mother and son investigators, suelees, 30th Apr 2008, #8
                                    RE: mother and son investigators, andyp4, 01st May 2008, #10
RE: mother and son investigators, Neil Bateman, 01st May 2008, #9
RE: mother and son investigators, suelees, 01st May 2008, #11

Derek
                              

CAB Adviser, Esher CAB
Member since
09th Mar 2004

RE: mother and son investigators
Tue 29-Apr-08 03:59 PM

So what was the point of the IUC then?

Rather reminds me of the Government Minister (quite a few years ago - I think it was Conservative then) who answered a question by saying "I'm quite prepared to listen to anything that supports the conclusion to which I've come."!

  

Top      

jj
                              

welfare rights adviser, saltley & nechells law centre birmingham
Member since
21st Jan 2004

RE: mother and son investigators
Tue 29-Apr-08 04:18 PM

creepy, isn't it? you don't suppose there's a secret breeding programme...?

  

Top      

nevip
                              

welfare rights adviser, sefton metropolitan borough council, liverpool.
Member since
22nd Jan 2004

RE: mother and son investigators
Wed 30-Apr-08 09:19 AM

Is that like the DWP's version of McMillan and Wife. For anyone under 40 just look up the 1970's.

  

Top      

andyp4
                              

Welfare Benefits Advisor, South Somerset District Council (Yeovil)
Member since
16th Jul 2007

RE: mother and son investigators
Wed 30-Apr-08 11:57 AM

I would prefer to think of them as the father and son characters in Hot Fuzz, don't know why other than i keeping getting these surreal thoughts about it.

  

Top      

nevip
                              

welfare rights adviser, sefton metropolitan borough council, liverpool.
Member since
22nd Jan 2004

RE: mother and son investigators
Wed 30-Apr-08 12:10 PM

What the hell is Hot Fuzz? Or dare I ask?

  

Top      

claire hodgson
                              

Solicitor, Askews Solicitors, Thornaby, Stockton on Tees
Member since
17th May 2005

RE: mother and son investigators
Wed 30-Apr-08 12:23 PM

"What the hell is Hot Fuzz? Or dare I ask?"

A Film, paul, very good apparently...

  

Top      

nevip
                              

welfare rights adviser, sefton metropolitan borough council, liverpool.
Member since
22nd Jan 2004

RE: mother and son investigators
Wed 30-Apr-08 12:33 PM

Thanks Claire. Thats something of a relief. I was starting to get a bit overheated there; my imagination starting to run away with me.

  

Top      

suelees
                              

Welfare and Debt Advisor, Stephensons Solicitors, Wigan
Member since
28th Jan 2004

RE: mother and son investigators
Wed 30-Apr-08 02:01 PM

I can see this going along similar lines as Mike's stiff man post

  

Top      

andyp4
                              

Welfare Benefits Advisor, South Somerset District Council (Yeovil)
Member since
16th Jul 2007

RE: mother and son investigators
Thu 01-May-08 09:41 AM

Paul, Hot Fuzz is a surreal comedy giving a great insight into rural policing, neighbourhood watch schemes, and Cake culture, made by the same people who made Shawn of the Dead (watch that too) and Space(d) a Channel 4 comedy from a few years ago.

Apparently it appeals to 30/40/50 something slackers/ex festival types, outdoor/warehouse party types from bygone times, graphic designers, animators, muso's,gardening types, social care types, alternative healy types, dodgy car sales wotsits,Travellers and Gypy worker oh and welfs too according to a simple straw poll we've conducted.

  

Top      

Neil Bateman
                              

Welfare rights consultant, www.neilbateman.co.uk
Member since
24th Jan 2004

RE: mother and son investigators
Thu 01-May-08 09:37 AM

On a serious note, I think it's unwise to use close relatives as co-investigators. If nothing else it has an appearance of bias which might undermine the credibility of their evidence.

The DWP's internal Code of Conduct and Good Practice for Investigators (which I obtained using FoI Act) states (at para 9) that investigators "...must declare any circumstances or interests that may affect their ability to conduct an investigation objectively, including but not limited to any relationship to or with a suspect, witness or informant or any personal interest in the outcome of an investigation or other civil or criminal proceedings".

I think this is broad enough to mean that parents and children should not jointly investigate cases.

It would be worth making further enquiries about whether such a declaration of interest was made and to seek disclosure of records concerning it.

  

Top      

suelees
                              

Welfare and Debt Advisor, Stephensons Solicitors, Wigan
Member since
28th Jan 2004

RE: mother and son investigators
Thu 01-May-08 09:54 AM

I'll go along those lines Neil - and thank you for your input. If it's ok I'll have to get back to you about it as I hold my hands up that I wouldn't know what to do next apart from flag it up at appeal.

  

Top      

Top Other benefit issues topic #3383First topic | Last topic