Discussion archive

Top Policy topic #1446

Subject: "ESA claim successes (or failures)" First topic | Last topic
Gareth Morgan
                              

Managing Director, Ferret Information Systems, Cardiff
Member since
20th Feb 2004

ESA claim successes (or failures)
Wed 15-Jul-09 02:21 PM

I've come across the article below which seems a bit surprising. Are these actually the kind of rates that people are finding?

"More than two-thirds of applicants for sickness benefits are being rejected under a new testing regime, casting doubt on the validity of 2.6m existing claimants deemed unfit for work.

According to data seen by several welfare industry figures, up to 90 per cent of applicants are being judged able to work in some regions and placed on unemployment rolls rather than long-term ill-health benefits.

The results, yet to be officially confirmed, offer an incoming government next year the chance to cut a £175bn budget deficit by forcing the long-term sick to seek work. A three-year programme starting in 2010 will subject 2.6m incapacity benefit claimants to the new work capability assessment.

Every person returning to work would reduce the £12.5bn total bill of incapacity benefit and start to pay some income tax and national insurance.

“These are remarkable figures,” said Lord Freud, Conservative welfare reform spokesman. “The tragedy is that it has taken so long to tighten the system, with the effect that hundreds of thousands of people have been locked
into long-term dependency.”

Initial results from the new test imply the bar for sickness benefits is at its highest level for decades. About 65 per cent of applications for incapacity benefit were approved until it was replaced last autumn – suggesting the
chances of passing and failing have been reversed under the new ill-health benefit, the “employment and support allowance”. "

  

Top      

Replies to this topic
RE: ESA claim successes (or failures), Ruth_T, 15th Jul 2009, #1
RE: ESA claim successes (or failures), pete c, 16th Jul 2009, #2

Ruth_T
                              

Volunteer adviser, Corby Welfare Rights Advice Bureau
Member since
03rd May 2005

RE: ESA claim successes (or failures)
Wed 15-Jul-09 07:22 PM

This article appeared in Monday's Financial Times (not well known as a supporter of working people) and was accompanied by a Leader article 'Benefit Reform is Long Overdue'.

I wondered about the figures as well, and am a little suspicious because they don't give a source, and also because the story was not picked up by other newspapers eg Guardian, The Times. Also I couldn't reconcile the figures with the Early Estimate Statistics for IB/ESA which were released today by ONS http://research.dwp.gov.uk/asd/asd1/tabtools/commentary_esaib.pdf


  

Top      

pete c
                              

Welfare Rights Officer, Adult Social Care, Cornwall County Council, Truro
Member since
30th Oct 2008

RE: ESA claim successes (or failures)
Thu 16-Jul-09 06:57 AM

If they are true then perhaps we should start a campaign to get the Secretary of State the Nobel Prize for medicine; 'curing' 90% of people whose own GPs had previously found to be too ill for work is a truly remarkable acheivment........

Sorry to be so cynical but its ill informed stories like this that deter genuinly ill people from claiming

  

Top      

Top Policy topic #1446First topic | Last topic