Discussion archive

Top Disability related benefits topic #6855

Subject: "dla overpayment" First topic | Last topic
scunny advisor
                              

advisor, Active Community Team, Scunthorpe
Member since
03rd Jun 2009

dla overpayment
Wed 03-Jun-09 12:01 PM

Can someone help me. I know a supersession means overpayment is recoverable but what I need to know for a tribunal is if a person claims dla but only mobility is then awarded care even though it is stated no care is needed can I argue that it is not his fault and therefore not a supersession and as it is the departments fault then surely it is not recoverable from the client.

  

Top      

Replies to this topic
RE: dla overpayment, ipr, 03rd Jun 2009, #1
RE: dla overpayment, Tony Bowman, 03rd Jun 2009, #4
      RE: dla overpayment, scunny advisor, 09th Jun 2009, #5
           RE: dla overpayment, nevip, 09th Jun 2009, #6
                RE: dla overpayment, scunny advisor, 10th Jun 2009, #7
                     RE: dla overpayment, ruthch, 10th Jun 2009, #8
                          RE: dla overpayment, shawn, 10th Jun 2009, #9

ipr
                              

Welfare Rights and Debt Advisor, Islington People's Rights
Member since
30th Sep 2008

RE: dla overpayment
Wed 03-Jun-09 10:47 AM

Hi.

Under section 71(1) of the Social Security Adminstration Act 1992, an overpayment is only recoverable if the person has 'misrepresented, or failed to disclose, any material fact' and that is the cause of the overpayment. If the person didn't say they had any care needs I don't see how it was their fault the overpayment arose and so it shouldn't be recoverable.

Cheers Ros

  

Top      

Tony Bowman
                              

Welfare Rights Advisor, Reading Community Welfare Rights Unit
Member since
25th Nov 2004

RE: dla overpayment
Wed 03-Jun-09 12:57 PM

What about where there is information included on the pages relating the mobility component which suggested that the care component was appropriate and which led to the award? In the normal course of events we would find ourselves arguing that the DM should take into account of this and, if appropriate make an award. The form is a means of gathering information and, for the most part, I really don't think it matters whereabouts on the form the information appears.

So, if it was just that the care-related questions were not touched at all, it could be more difficult than the previous contributor suggests to argue for non-recovery.

If it was the case that the claimant stated on the form "I do not want any care component" then the previous contributors argument is stronger but leads to the inevitable question: why didn't your client query the award of care component?

Regardless of this, if the supersession was based on a change of circs relating to disability and PDCS can prove there was a relevant change, then it would be difficult to argue against a failure to disclose.

I hope this makes sense.

  

Top      

scunny advisor
                              

advisor, Active Community Team, Scunthorpe
Member since
03rd Jun 2009

RE: dla overpayment
Tue 09-Jun-09 12:54 PM

the judge asked me to look at cdla 3508 2006 which blows my submission out can anyone point me to a case law to combat this ?

many thanks

  

Top      

nevip
                              

welfare rights adviser, sefton metropolitan borough council, liverpool.
Member since
22nd Jan 2004

RE: dla overpayment
Tue 09-Jun-09 05:02 PM

Do you mean CDLA/2328/2006? Unable to find CDLA/3508/2006.

  

Top      

scunny advisor
                              

advisor, Active Community Team, Scunthorpe
Member since
03rd Jun 2009

RE: dla overpayment
Wed 10-Jun-09 08:50 AM

It is 3508 2006 a tribunal revision or upper tier decision

  

Top      

ruthch
                              

Senior Welfare Rights Officer, Tameside MBC
Member since
10th Feb 2005

RE: dla overpayment
Wed 10-Jun-09 10:41 AM

The decision is in the toolkit area of rightsnet.

  

Top      

shawn
                              

editorial director, rightsnet
Member since
28th Jul 2005

RE: dla overpayment
Wed 10-Jun-09 11:08 AM

.... @ http://www.rightsnet.org.uk/toolkit_1358-3108-13695.html

  

Top      

Top Disability related benefits topic #6855First topic | Last topic