Discussion archive

Top Decision Making and Appeals topic #3472

Subject: "When the effective date of renewal is different to the date the decision is made, which date is impo..." First topic | Last topic
iut044
                              

Advisor, South West Lancashire Independent Community Advice
Member since
15th May 2007

When the effective date of renewal is different to the date the decision is made, which date is impo...
Tue 01-Sep-09 11:41 AM

Hi

I am assisting a client with a Disability Living Allowance appeal. The effective date of renewal was 02/04/2009 but the date that the decision was made was 06/02/2009. Which date is important to the tribunal?

Thanks

  

Top      

Replies to this topic
RE: When the effective date of renewal is different to the date the decision is made, which date is ..., Allan Hind, 03rd Sep 2009, #1
RE: When the effective date of renewal is different to the date the decision is made, which date is ..., iut044, 03rd Sep 2009, #2
      RE: When the effective date of renewal is different to the date the decision is made, which date is ..., ariadne2, 03rd Sep 2009, #3
           RE: When the effective date of renewal is different to the date the decision is made, which date is ..., iut044, 04th Sep 2009, #4
           RE: When the effective date of renewal is different to the date the decision is made, which date is ..., donewithwr, 04th Sep 2009, #5
           RE: When the effective date of renewal is different to the date the decision is made, which date is ..., iut044, 04th Sep 2009, #6

Allan Hind
                              

Welfare Rights Officer, Northumberland NHS Care Trust
Member since
15th Aug 2007

RE: When the effective date of renewal is different to the date the decision is made, which date is ...
Thu 03-Sep-09 12:40 PM

Both dates will be of importance to the tribunal. The 06/02/09 date is the date your client will have to show was appealled against in good time. Is this the question you are pondering?

Allan

  

Top      

iut044
                              

Advisor, South West Lancashire Independent Community Advice
Member since
15th May 2007

RE: When the effective date of renewal is different to the date the decision is made, which date is ...
Thu 03-Sep-09 03:08 PM

Thanks for your help Allan, the question I am asking is which is the date where the client will have to have had met the disability condition from?

  

Top      

ariadne2
                              

Welfare lawyer and social policy collator, Basingstoke CAB
Member since
13th Mar 2007

RE: When the effective date of renewal is different to the date the decision is made, which date is ...
Thu 03-Sep-09 06:54 PM

The most important point where the date of the decision predates the date of the renewal is that any changes between the two dates cannot be taken into account on appeal.

If you are arguing for a change that will result in a higher rate of benefit, then the additional need will have had to be in place for three months before the higher rate can be paid. So say the deterioration had only just happened by the date of the decision, it would be open to the DM to make an award from the three months deadline, ie in the future, possibly even after the renewal date. If however the deterioration was after the date of decision but before date of renewal, you'll need to put in another supersession application.

  

Top      

iut044
                              

Advisor, South West Lancashire Independent Community Advice
Member since
15th May 2007

RE: When the effective date of renewal is different to the date the decision is made, which date is ...
Fri 04-Sep-09 08:42 AM

Thanks very much for your detailed approach.

  

Top      

donewithwr
                              

macmillan welfare rights officer, rotherham metropolitan borough council
Member since
20th Aug 2009

RE: When the effective date of renewal is different to the date the decision is made, which date is ...
Fri 04-Sep-09 10:02 AM

you might want to read tribunal of commissioner's decisionsCDLA.2751.2003,CDLA.3567.2003 and CDLA.3275.2003

  

Top      

iut044
                              

Advisor, South West Lancashire Independent Community Advice
Member since
15th May 2007

RE: When the effective date of renewal is different to the date the decision is made, which date is ...
Fri 04-Sep-09 02:17 PM

So does the three month backward qualifying period cover the three months before the date of renewal?

  

Top      

Top Decision Making and Appeals topic #3472First topic | Last topic