Discussion archive

Top Disability related benefits topic #7393

Subject: "Second Property ESA refusal" First topic | Last topic
GLON
                              

Welfare Rights Officer, Norfolk County Council
Member since
02nd Oct 2009

Second Property ESA refusal
Mon 14-Dec-09 03:09 PM

I have a client who has stiff person syndrome ( one of only 3 people ). She is living with her parents until she has her own property adpated to meet her needs. She has not started the work on the home as she has not been fully assessed as to what her needs are. She does want to go home but it could be a long process before all the relevant support is in place.
She is staying with her parents on the weekend and the rest of the week in hospital, when she does leave hospital full-time in the new year she will be staying with her parents. She has made a claim for (IB) ESA but has be turned down because it has been deemed she has second property (that is her own home). JCP has argued she lives with her parents.
Has any one any ideas or know of any case law that could help in getting ESA awarded.
Thank you.

  

Top      

Replies to this topic

Rob_Price
                              

Principal Welfare & Income Officer, Shropshire County Council
Member since
02nd Dec 2004

RE: Second Property ESA refusal
Mon 14-Dec-09 05:20 PM

Look at ESA Regs, schedule 9, para 2, and CIS/8475/95. paras 16 to 18. The property should be disregarded for 26 weeks or longer: it's what's reasonable in the circumstances. See if you can get confirmation that she's on the waiting list to have the premises or herself assessed for needs- Social Services? (Big waiting lists, I know). Go for reconsideration rather than appeal at this stage. They should cave.

Here's a couple of useful links:

http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2008/uksi_20080794_en_25#sch9

http://www.rightsnet.org.uk/pdfs/cmmr_upload/cis/cis847595.doc
Okay, so it's IS, but exactly the same principles apply to ESA.

Cut and paste the regs right back at 'em.

This is from the DMG:
52551 The value of any premises which the claimant has acquired with the intention of living in as their home within 26 weeks of the date of acquisition should be disregarded. Where the claimant intends to live in the premises but it will be later than 26 weeks from acquisition, then a longer period can be considered where it is reasonable to enable the claimant to obtain possession and begin occupation1.
1 ESA Regs, Sch 9, para 2

You might wish to quote that back at 'em too.

Good luck.

  

Top      

Top Disability related benefits topic #7393First topic | Last topic