Decision makers statement

Does anyone know

Is there such a thing as a decision makers statement, a report of sorts that decision makers have to file each time they make a decision that would perhaps show some more light on the inner workings of decisions aside from the end result letters

?

“Secretary of State’s Response” in an appeal submission is usually the only way to actually see a written rationale (term used loosely!) for decisions.

I tend to work on the basis that there are rarely anything resembling “inner workings” when it comes to decision making. The time spent worrying about such things is better spent throwing a challenge against the wall to see what sticks.

If I want to know the rationale for a decision I’ll get it to an appeal tribunal and watch a generally garbled template submission fall to pieces.

Occasionally, I come across a print-screen from one or another piece of departmental software. There’s rarely anything revealing there. It’s pretty neutral and stock phrases tend to be used, although it may be better than what finds its way onto the decision letter.

I agree that rather than guessing what the DM was thinking, to decide for yourself what’s true and challenge the DM’s findings on this basis. After all, if s/he has concluded something without giving the “real” reasons and your conclusions are more inherently probable, the tribunal should go with the conclusion that is better supported by the facts.