Discussion archive

Top Housing Benefit & Council Tax Benefit topic #5842

Subject: "R v Stratford upon Avon DC ex p White" First topic | Last topic
GAD
                              

Welfare Rights Officer, Welfare Rights Service,Lancashire County Council
Member since
15th Dec 2004

R v Stratford upon Avon DC ex p White
Wed 05-Dec-07 10:08 AM

Has anybody got a copy of this decision they could email me or point me to where I can find it? Thought I had seen it somewhere on Rightsnet but can't locate it.

Many thanks.

  

Top      

Replies to this topic
RE: R v Stratford upon Avon DC ex p White, Tony Bowman, 05th Dec 2007, #1
RE: R v Stratford upon Avon DC ex p White, Coach, 06th Dec 2007, #2
      RE: R v Stratford upon Avon DC ex p White, GAD, 07th Dec 2007, #3
           RE: R v Stratford upon Avon DC ex p White, david fernie, 07th Dec 2007, #4
                RE: R v Stratford upon Avon DC ex p White, GAD, 07th Dec 2007, #5
                     RE: R v Stratford upon Avon DC ex p White, Kevin D, 07th Dec 2007, #6
                          RE: R v Stratford upon Avon DC ex p White, GAD, 07th Dec 2007, #7
                               RE: R v Stratford upon Avon DC ex p White, Kevin D, 07th Dec 2007, #8

Tony Bowman
                              

Welfare Rights Advisor, Reading Community Welfare Rights Unit
Member since
25th Nov 2004

RE: R v Stratford upon Avon DC ex p White
Wed 05-Dec-07 12:19 PM

all i could find was this summary:

http://www.lgtraining.freeserve.co.uk/archives/luarch/houseben.htm

  

Top      

Coach
                              

Housing caseworker, Bury Law Centre
Member since
25th Sep 2007

RE: R v Stratford upon Avon DC ex p White
Thu 06-Dec-07 07:54 AM

Gad,

Go to Bailii.org. Here is the link to it. It must be a Carsberg link because its probably the biggest I have ever seen.

http://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/sino_search_1.cgi?sort=rank&datehigh=&query=title%20(%20White%20)&method=boolean&highlight=1&datelow=&mask_path=/eu/cases%20/ew/cases%20/ie/cases%20/nie/cases%20/scot/cases%20/uk/cases

  

Top      

GAD
                              

Welfare Rights Officer, Welfare Rights Service,Lancashire County Council
Member since
15th Dec 2004

RE: R v Stratford upon Avon DC ex p White
Fri 07-Dec-07 09:04 AM

Thanks for that but somebody has offered to email it to me. Just as well because I spent about an hour looking for it on bailli without success (a reflection of my IT skills rather than anything else). Think the link was so big it must have given up halfway through!

  

Top      

david fernie
                              

WRO, Appeals Section, Glasgow City Council
Member since
14th May 2004

RE: R v Stratford upon Avon DC ex p White
Fri 07-Dec-07 10:09 AM

A shorter link:

http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Admin/1997/17.html

David

  

Top      

GAD
                              

Welfare Rights Officer, Welfare Rights Service,Lancashire County Council
Member since
15th Dec 2004

RE: R v Stratford upon Avon DC ex p White
Fri 07-Dec-07 10:33 AM

Thanks for that. I've realised that the case has been misspelt on bailli ("Statford" instead of "Stratford") which is why my earlier searches failed!

I understand that this case was overturned at the Court of Appeal(?). I'll try to locate this on bailli (using a variety of different spellings of Stratford probably) but may come back for further assistance if thst's ok.

  

Top      

Kevin D
                              

Freelance HB & CTB Consultant/Trainer, Hertfordshire
Member since
20th Jan 2004

RE: R v Stratford upon Avon DC ex p White
Fri 07-Dec-07 02:29 PM

The Court of Appeal case can be found on the following link:

www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/1998/478.html

In my view, it's important to read both the HC AND the CA judgements.

There is some commentary/analysis about this case in the CPAG book.

  

Top      

GAD
                              

Welfare Rights Officer, Welfare Rights Service,Lancashire County Council
Member since
15th Dec 2004

RE: R v Stratford upon Avon DC ex p White
Fri 07-Dec-07 02:37 PM

Thanks Kevin. As anticipated, I couldn't find it on bailli.

I'll try and backtrack from this link to see where I went wrong.

  

Top      

Kevin D
                              

Freelance HB & CTB Consultant/Trainer, Hertfordshire
Member since
20th Jan 2004

RE: R v Stratford upon Avon DC ex p White
Fri 07-Dec-07 04:43 PM

A few months ago, the search mechanism changed on Bailii. Since that change, I have found it is better to go instantly to "Advanced Search".

In the "Enter your query" field, the best way tends to be using muiltiple words, using "and" as the linking mechanism. Also, by enclosing a specific "string", that will further narrow the search.

For example, to find the CA judgement for "White", try:

"white and stratford and "housing benefit""

That gives about 49 "hits". But most of those aren't case citations, so you just end up looking at the remainder. So long as you know that cases going to the next court aren't always with the same lead party, it soon becomes apparent which case is the relevant case.

In "White", it became known as "Addy", but it still appears, albeit at about hit number 45. If you prioritise by date, most CA cases occur within 3 years of the HC case, so will tend to be nearby in the listings.

Hope this helps.



have

  

Top      

Top Housing Benefit & Council Tax Benefit topic #5842First topic | Last topic