Discussion archive

Top Incapacity related benefits topic #3489

Subject: "Vision descriptor of PCA help needed" First topic | Last topic
dbcwru
                              

Welfare Rights Officer, Darlington Welfare Rights
Member since
25th Nov 2005

Vision descriptor of PCA help needed
Tue 02-Dec-08 08:49 AM

Can any one help with this. I have a client who has a problem with vision that would be corrected with glasses, but he refuses to wear glasses as he could only afford NHS frames. Can he be treated as still having a visual problem under the PCA?

  

Top      

Replies to this topic
RE: Vision descriptor of PCA help needed, Henri, 02nd Dec 2008, #1
RE: Vision descriptor of PCA help needed, ariadne2, 02nd Dec 2008, #2
      RE: Vision descriptor of PCA help needed, dbcwru, 03rd Dec 2008, #3

Henri
                              

Advice & Information Team Leader, Off Centre, Hackney
Member since
19th May 2006

RE: Vision descriptor of PCA help needed
Tue 02-Dec-08 09:35 AM

The problem is going to be with the DM rather than the medical service - if your client cannot show good cause for refusing medical treatment then he could be disqualified for a period or deemed to have failed.

  

Top      

ariadne2
                              

Welfare lawyer and social policy collator, Basingstoke CAB
Member since
13th Mar 2007

RE: Vision descriptor of PCA help needed
Tue 02-Dec-08 03:59 PM

See CIB/14499/1996, where the Commissioner interpreted the use of aids as meaning "if the aid in question is generally worn by people in the claimant's situation acting reasonably." The effect of this is tht if a person would be able to see perfectly well wearing glasses but unreasonably refuses to, they score no points. The case was on hearing aids, but the same applies. It is in fact much more likely that a person will have a good reason not to wear hearing aids, as they can be very uncomfortable and cause irritation and even infection of the ear canal. The better analogy for vision is contact lenses.

  

Top      

dbcwru
                              

Welfare Rights Officer, Darlington Welfare Rights
Member since
25th Nov 2005

RE: Vision descriptor of PCA help needed
Wed 03-Dec-08 07:55 AM

Thanks all.

  

Top      

Top Incapacity related benefits topic #3489First topic | Last topic